Great wines & spirits

FINE WINES & SPIRITS

Date : February 20, 2024

Venue: Étude AGUTTES in Neuilly-sur-Seine - 164 bis Avenue Charles de Gaulle - 92200

• 1st part of the sale from 11am to 1pm (lots 1 to 249)
• 2nd part of the sale from 2:30pm (lots 250 to last)

The sale will be held by appointment.

Buyer's fee: 25% inc VAT (excluding live charges)

Exhibition :

no exhibition, condition reports on request at nourry@aguttes.com or boudemange@aguttes.com

Specialist :

Pierre-Luc NOURRY - 07 63 44 69 56 - nourry@aguttes.com

Expert :

Denis BERNARD - 06 80 65 89 04

Lives: Drouot Online and Interenchères Live

SAS AGUTTES (“AGUTTES”) is an operator of voluntary public auctions, registered with the “Conseil des maisons de vente” and governed by Articles L.321-4 et seq. of the French Commercial Code. In this capacity AGUTTES acts under a sales mandate as the seller’s authorised representative who contracts with the successful bidder.

The present General Terms and Conditions of Sale (“GTCS”) govern the relationship between AGUTTES and bidders for public auctions and private sales organised by AGUTTES.

AGUTTES may modify the GTCS in writing and/or orally prior to the sale. These modifications will be mentioned in the minutes of the sale.

Description of lots: The information provided in the auction catalogues engages the civil liability of AGUTTES and its experts, subject to the provisions mentioned below. Only indications in the French language are binding on AGUTTES to the exclusion of any translations, which are free. They may be subject to modifications or corrections until the moment of the auction in writing or orally. These modifications shall be recorded in the report of the auction, which will have probative force. 

No other guarantee is given by AGUTTES, it being recalled that only the seller is bound by the warranty for hidden defects and the legal warranty of conformity. A certificate of authenticity of the lot will only be available if mentioned in the description of the lot.

The dimensions, weights and other information of the lots are given as an indication with a reasonable margin of error.

Restorations carried out as a precautionary measure, without altering the age and style characteristics, and which do not modify the specific nature of the lot, will not be mentioned in the description.

The absence of any indication of restoration, accident or incident in the catalogue or condition reports shall in no way imply that the lot is free from any past, present or repaired defect. Conversely, the mention of any defect does not imply the absence of other defects.

Special mentions appearing in the auction catalogue have the following meanings: 

+  Lots forming part of a judicial sale following a court order entail the following buyer’s fees: 14.40% including all taxes;

° Lots, in which AGUTTES or one of its partners has financial interests;

* Lots under temporary importation: subject to a 5.5% fee for works of art, collectibles and antiques (20% for wines and spirits, jewellery and multiples), to be borne by the buyer in addition to the selling costs and the auction price, unless the buyer resides outside the EU;

¤ Goods sold under the general VAT regime (for the total);

# Lots visible only by appointment;

~  Lots made from materials derived from animal species. Import restrictions may apply. 

Condition of lots: The lots are sold in the condition in which they are found at the time of sale with their imperfections and defects. As the lots are second-hand goods, no guarantee can be given as to their condition. 

References to the condition of a lot in a catalogue or condition report may not be considered as an exhaustive description of the condition of said lot. Descriptions may not under any circumstances replace the personal examination of the lot as indicated below. Condition reports will be sent upon request but for indicative purposes only. 

Preview of the lots: Potential bidders are required to personally examine the lots and documents available prior to the auction at a private appointment or at the public preview in order to verify the condition of the lots. Buyers are advised to be accompanied by an expert in the sector concerned by the auction.

Reproduction of lots: Not all defects and imperfections of the lots are visible in the photographs of the lots reproduced in the catalogues, online or in any other communication medium. Photographs may not provide an entirely faithful image of the actual condition of a lot and may differ from what would be perceived by a direct observer (size, colour, etc.). 

Estimates: Estimates are based on the state of technical knowledge on the day of the estimate, the quality of the lot, its provenance, its condition and the market conditions on the day of the estimate. They are provided for information purposes only and cannot be considered as a guarantee that the lot will be sold at the estimated price. 

II- THE AUCTION

Registration for the auction: Important: the normal and priority method for bidding is to be present in the auction room. As a service, other methods are possible that require prior registration:

-   By telephone: AGUTTES accepts, free of charge, to receive bids by telephone only for bidders who come forward before 6 p.m., on the last business day before the auction. The potential bidder must have received a prior confirmation email from AGUTTES to be called. 

-   By purchase order: Any person previously registered and wishing to bid will have the option to request the registration of purchase orders with AGUTTES on their behalf. The order must have been communicated in writing before 6 p.m. on the last business day before the auction, and the bidder must have received a confirmation email from AGUTTES. No unlimited order will be accepted. If AGUTTES receives multiple purchase orders for identical bidding amounts, the oldest order will be preferred.

-   Online via Live platforms: An option for online bidding is available on platforms allowing remote participation in auctions electronically, upon prior registration. Purchasers using Live platforms are informed that the fees charged by these platforms will be at their exclusive expense.

Participation in the auctions by telephone, internet or order is carried out at the bidder’s own risk and peril and AGUTTES cannot be held liable in the event of non-participation of the auction bidder for any reason whatsoever, particularly in the event of malfunction or default of any kind (lack of response from the bidder, error, interruption or omission in the reception of bids). Any malfunction or interruption of the telephone or live service will not prevent the auctioneer from continuing the auction, at his discretion.

Procedure for identifying bidders: AGUTTES reserves the right to ask any potential bidder to prove their identity and for a legal entity, to provide a Kbis extract less than three months old and its bank details, it being specified that only the legal representative of the company or any duly authorised person may bid on its behalf. In the event of non-compliance with the identification procedures, AGUTTES reserves the right to refuse auction registration. All lots sold will be invoiced in the name and address of the purchaser. No subsequent modification may be made. The bidder is deemed to act in his own name and will be solely responsible for the bids made unless duly registered beforehand that he is acting as an official agent of a third party in accordance with the conditions indicated below.

Any false information shall incur the liability of the successful bidder.

Mandate by a third party: The bidder with a mandate must inform AGUTTES of its existence during the identification and registration procedure and produce a copy of the mandate and any other documents requested by AGUTTES. In such a case, the bidder and the principal shall be jointly and severally liable.  

Conduct of the auction: The auctioneer conducts the auction in a discretionary manner, ensuring the freedom and equality among all bidders, while respecting the established practices and customs of the profession. The auctioneer ensures the policing of the auction, which allows him to refuse bids or to withdraw a lot without having to justify it.

Adjudication: The highest final bid will be deemed the successful bidder, all accepted means of bidding combined (order, internet, telephone, on-site, etc.). The adjudication is formalised by the pronouncement of the word “Sold” in French (“Adjugé”), which forms the sales agreement between the seller and the successful bidder.

Each lot is identified with a number corresponding to the number assigned to it in the auction catalogue. 

Sellers are prohibited from bidding directly on the lots they own. 

In the event of a simultaneous “double-bid” recognised by the auctioneer, the lot will be put back up for auction again, with all bidders present being able to participate in this second adjudication.

Withdrawal: Each bid and adjudication is final and binds the person who placed it. The successful bidder may not withdraw his or her bid, whether they are present in the auction room, on the telephone, online or have placed a purchase order. 

Transfer of risks and ownership: The transfer of ownership and risks between the seller and the successful bidder occurs when the auctioneer pronounces the word “sold” in French (“Adjugé”). AGUTTES disclaims any liability for losses and damages that the lots may suffer from the moment of adjudication.  The successful bidder must insure the acquired lots as soon as the lot is adjudicated to him.

Buyer’s premium: In addition to the hammer price, the successful bidder must pay a fixed buyer’s premium, due for each acquired lot, calculated as follows: 

- 25% (excluding taxes) + VAT at the prevailing rate, i.e. 30% (including taxes) for the first €150,000 

- 23 % (excluding taxes) + VAT at the prevailing rate, i.e. 27,6 % (including taxes) for amounts exceeding € 150,001. 

Exception: For books which benefit from a reduced VAT rate: 25% (excluding taxes), i.e. 26.37% (including taxes).

In addition to the hammer price and the buyer’s premium, the successful bidder must pay all taxes and duties including VAT as well as any administrative, handling, and storage costs.

Payment of the sums due must be made in one single instalment by the successful bidder, immediately after adjudication. Payment is made in euros. Any potential bank charges applicable will not be deducted from the amounts due. 

VAT: The VAT rate is 20% (or 5.5% for books). As a matter of principle, unmarked lots will be sold under the VAT gross margin scheme. The buyer’s premium and additional costs will be increased by an amount in lieu of VAT, which will not be separately mentioned in our sale slips. 

By way of exception, and at the request of the seller, the general VAT system may be applied to goods offered for auction by an EU professional. These goods will be marked by the ¤ sign. 

Possible VAT refunds: apply for 

1- The professional from the European Union, (i) with an intra-Community VAT number and (ii) providing proof of the export of lots from France to another Member State;

2- Non-residents of the European Union upon provision of (i) a customs export document, on which AGUTTES appears as sender (ii) when the export occurs within three months of the auction date or the date of obtaining the export permit.

Payment terms: Legal payment methods accepted by AGUTTES’ accounting (payments by credit card or wire transfer are strongly recommended): 

- Credit card: bank charges, which usually vary between 1 and 2%, are not borne by the auction house;

- American Express card: a commission of 2.95% (including taxes) will be charged for all payments. Remote card payments and split payments in several instalments for the same lot with the same card are not allowed;

- Online payment: up to €10,000 to https://www.aguttes.com/paiement-en-ligne

- Bank transfer: from the buyer’s account and indicating the invoice number: 

IBAN FR76 3006 6109 1300 0203 7410 222 

BIC CMCIFRPP 

Account holder AGUTTES 

Direct debit CIC PARIS ETOILE ENTREPRISES 

178 RUE DE COURCELLES - 75017 PARIS

- Cash:  Articles L.112-6 and D.112-3 of the French Monetary and Financial Code: (i) Up to €1,000 for French tax residents or individuals acting for the purposes of a professional activity; (ii) Up to €15,000 for individuals whose tax residence is abroad (upon presentation of a passport and proof of residence);

- Cheque (as a last resort): Upon presentation of two forms of identification documents. No time limit for cashing is accepted in the event of payment by cheque. Issuance will only be possible twenty days after payment. Foreign cheques are not accepted. 

Defaulting successful bidder: In the absence of timely payment by the buyer, the item may be put back up for auction upon reiteration of the bids at the seller’s request in accordance with the procedure of Article L.321-14 of the French Commercial Code. If the seller does not make this request within three months of the auction, the sale shall be automatically cancelled. 

In all cases, the defaulting buyer, due to lack of payment, shall be held liable to pay AGUTTES: 

- All costs and incidental expenses incurred by AGUTTES relating to the collection of unpaid invoices (including legal fees);

- Late payment penalties calculated by applying interest rates at the European Central Bank (ECB) semi-annual key rate (refinancing rate or Refi) increased by five points on the total amount;

- Damages to compensate for the loss suffered by AGUTTES (purchase costs, fees and commissions, VAT, storage, etc.). 

AGUTTES reserves the right to:

- Communicate the name and contact details of the defaulting buyer to the seller in order to enable the latter to assert their rights; 

- Exercise or have exercised all the rights and remedies, in particular the right of retention, over any property of the defaulting buyer, of which AGUTTES may have custody;

- Prohibit the defaulting successful bidder from bidding in future auctions organised by AGUTTES or make the possibility of bidding in future auctions contingent upon the payment of a prior provision;

- Proceed to the registration of the defaulting bidder on a database of bad payers shared among different participating auction houses.

Indeed, AGUTTES is a member of the Central Register for the prevention of unpaid dues of auctioneers upon which incidents of non-payment are likely to be registered.

The rights to access, rectify and object for legitimate reasons may be exercised by the concerned debtor at Symev 15 rue Freycinet 75016 Paris.

Collection and storage of lots: An awarded lot may only be delivered to the buyer after full payment of the purchase slip, received by the AGUTTES bank account. 

The lots will be handed over to the purchaser in person after presentation of any document proving his identity or to the third party appointed by him and to whom he has entrusted an original power of attorney and a copy of his identity document. The lot is collected at the buyer’s sole risk and expenses. 

Lots that have not been collected on the same day after the end of the auction must be collected by the buyer upon appointment with the person mentioned for this purpose on the contact page at the beginning of the auction catalogue. The location of the collection place will be indicated in the email accompanying the invoice.

The applicable storage fees are mentioned in the "Special Terms and Conditions" below.

Resale of paid and non-collected lots: In the event that one or more lots awarded and paid for in the course of an auction have still not been collected by the buyer within the timeframe agreed upon in the "Special Terms and Conditions" below  and that the applicable storage, custody and preservation costs exceed the auction value of the lot(s), AGUTTES reserves the right to put the lot(s) back up for auction or sale in order to reimburse all costs due.

The French State may exercise a pre-emptive right on any public or private sale or auction of cultural property. The State has a period of 15 days from the public sale to confirm the exercise of its pre-emptive right to buy and to subrogate itself to the buyer. 

The export formalities (requests for certificate for a cultural good, export license) for a given lot are the responsibility of the purchaser and may require a four-month delay. AGUTTES is at the disposal of its buyers to guide them through these procedures and to assist them in the submission of requests to the French Museums Service (“Service des Musées de France”).  

AGUTTES cannot be held responsible for delays. Under no circumstances can AGUTTES be held liable for the refusal or delay of the administrative decision. The refusal to issue a certificate or a license may not under any circumstances justify a default or delay in payment by the buyer or a cancellation of the sale.

The present GTCS and the rights and obligations arising from them will be governed by French law. 

Any legal action relating to the sales activities of AGUTTES will be settled by the competent Judicial Court in France, in accordance with article L.321-37 of the French Commercial Code. In particular, all legal actions involving successful bidders and/or bidders with the status of commercial traders according to French law will be decided by the Nanterre Judicial Court. 

Bidders, successful bidders and their representatives acknowledge that Neuilly-sur-Seine is the exclusive place of performance of AGUTTES' services. 

Civil liability claims arising from auctions and voluntary and judicial sales of furniture by public auction are subject to a limitation period of five years from the date of the auction.

Any difficulty may be referred free of charge to the Government Commissioner at the “Conseil des maisons de vente” with a view to reaching an amicable solution. Complaints may be made by post to 19 avenue de l'Opéra, 75001 Paris, or online at the following link: https://conseilmaisonsdevente.fr/en/claim. It is also possible to submit a request for an out-of-court settlement on a European platform for the settlement of online disputes between consumers and professionals, accessible at the following link: https://ec.europa.eu/consumers/odr/main/index.cfm?event=main.home2.show&lng=EN.

Bidders are informed that AGUTTES may collect and process data concerning them in accordance with the General Data Protection Regulation no. 2016/679 of 27 April 2016 (GDPR) and the French Data Protection Act no. 78-17 of 6 January 1978 amended by Law No. 2018-493 of 20 June 2018 on the protection of personal data.

Data is collected for the purposes of managing their contractual or pre-contractual relations (registration for auction, invoicing, accounting, payments, communication, etc.). This data consists of information such as: surname, first names, postal address, email address, telephone number, bank details. 

Bidders are informed that they have a right of access, rectification, erasure, portability, opposition, and limitation with regard to such data with AGUTTES. Requests must be made in writing to: communication@aguttes.com. Any complaint about the applicable data protection legislation may be brought before the CNIL: www.cnil.fr. 

AGUTTES owns all reproduction rights to its auction catalogue. Any reproduction thereof is prohibited and constitutes a counterfeiting. The sale of a lot does not in any way imply the assignment of any applicable intellectual property rights (representation and/or reproduction) to the work. 

IX- SPECIAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS

The storage of goods subject to an auction or a private sale that are not collected by the buyer within 15 days of the auction (including the day of the sale), will be charged as follows: 

- Jewellery and / or watches worth < €10.000 = €15 / day of storage 

- Jewellery and / or watches worth > €10.001 = €30 / day of storage 

- Other lots < 1m3 = €3 / day 

- Other lots > 1m3 = €5 / day.

Mechanical or electrical objects offered for sale by AGUTTES are exclusively offered for decorative purposes. As they represent second-hand goods, AGUTTES does not under any circumstances certify their operational condition. We recommend that buyers inspect the lots during the public preview of an auction accompanied by an expert in the concerned sector, and to have the electrical or mechanical mechanism checked by a professional before any operation of the lot.

The watches and clocks we sell are all second-hand goods, most of which have undergone repairs resulting in the replacement of certain parts which may not be original. AGUTTES does not provide any guarantee on the authenticity and originality of the components of a timekeeping item. 

Clocks may be sold without pendulums, weights, or keys and unless otherwise stated, their presence is not guaranteed. Watch straps may not be original and may not be authentic.

Collector’s watches require general and regular maintenance: repairs or overhauls may be necessary and are the responsibility of the buyer, as AGUTTES does not provide any guarantee on their proper functioning. AGUTTES recommends that buyers have watches and clocks checked by a competent watchmaker before each use. 

It is the responsibility of potential buyers to personally verify the condition of the item.

Unless expressly stated in the lot description, the presence of keys is not guaranteed.

Objects partially or entirely composed of materials from endangered and/or protected species of flora and fauna are marked by the symbol ~ in the catalogue. Legislators impose strict rules for the commercial use of these materials, in particular regarding ivory trade.  

Buyers are informed that the import of any goods composed of these materials is prohibited by many countries, or requires a permit or certificate issued by the competent authorities of the countries of export and import of the goods. Purchasers are entirely responsible for the proper compliance with all regulatory and legislative standards applicable to the export or import of goods composed partially or entirely of materials originating from endangered and/or protected species. AGUTTES will not be held liable for the impossibility of exporting or importing such goods, and this cannot be used to justify a request for cancellation of the sale.  

If a customer feels that he or she has not received a satisfactory response, he or she is advised to contact the head of the relevant department directly, as a matter of priority. In the absence of a response within the specified timeframe, the customer may then contact customer service at serviceclients@aguttes.com, which is attached to the Quality Management Department of SVV Aguttes.